UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone!
  George Spellwin's ELITE FITNESS Discussion Boards
  Diet Discussion Board
  How's this for a diet? Critique it if ya want

Post New Topic  
profile | register | preferences | faq | search

Author Topic:   How's this for a diet? Critique it if ya want
Diablo's Xstasy
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 75)
posted June 30, 2000 01:37 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Diablo's Xstasy   Click Here to Email Diablo's Xstasy     Edit/Delete Message
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Well here's my new and final diet what I am going to be eating for a very long long time so before I go food shopping for the next month I was hoping MS, or fitnesschick, and/or warlobo can look this over and make sure it's alright and up to snuff.
First of all:
21 Female 5'1 140lbs 30%bf -measured as of today, I am going to be taking specific body measurements tomorrow bi's, leg's, hip's, etc.
Goals: whocares about what I weight, but I would like to be 15% bodyfat. I'm not working on getting huge, but if it happens it happens, I would like to be very toned- and no not like a Jane Fonda toned. =o)
Workout scheadule:
Monday
am- Cardio & abs
pm- Shoulders, traps, & forearms
Tuesday
am(only until July16th then none) Cardio
pm- Back, Bi's, Yoga
Wednesday
am-cardio & abs
Thursday
am- cardio (only until July 16th then none)
pm- Chest, Tris, yoga
Friday
am- cardio & abs
pm- legs
Saturday
light cardio, if we dont go out dancing
Sunday
rest
Now here's the big part my diet:
Just to keep in mind I got all of the numbers from a ketogenic website that had a food list there so until I go shopping and pick out foods these numbers are approximate, but I will keep as close to them as possible.
Also for flax seed oil I did not know the numbers so I used Olive oil figuring they would be somewhat the same.
The totals are:
Cal Carb Pro Fat
1202 97 99.5 48.25
I have to find a protien powder to add cal and Protien as I want my calories up near 1800 and my protien not much more then 150g.

This is my daily plan:
8am- Wake up Cardio/ab routine
9am-(after workout/cardio carb meal)
cal carb Pro fat
3 egg whites 45 0 12 0
2 pks Oatmeal 210 36 8 4
1cu Skim Milk 85 12 8 0
Oil 1/2tbsp 62.5 0 0 7
402.5 48 28 11
12pm-(protien meal)
1can tuna 150 0 32.5 1.25
1/2tbsp Mayo 50 0 0 5.5
2 cup lettuce 5 1 1 0
1tbsplghtItal 5 2 0 0
oil 1/2tbsp 62.5 0 0 7
272.5 3 33.5 13.75
Cal Carb Pro Fat
4pm-(before work out carb meal)
1 lg apple 125 32 0 1
oil 1/2tbsp 62.5 0 0 7
1tbsp PeaBut 95 3 5 8
282.5 35 5 16
6pm- workout & yoga or cardio
9pm-(post workoutmeal)
4pcsChicktend 120 1 29 .5
2cMixedVeg 62 10 4 0
oil 1/2tbsp 62.5 0 0 7
244.5 11 33 7.5

Totals again:
1202 97 99.5 48.25

The tuna, chicken and Veggies are exact values gotten off the one's I already have.

Any comments, critiques, or otherwise inform me and I'm happy to hear them.

Actually, I'm pretty proud of myself.
DX

IP: Logged

brumans2
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 145)
posted June 30, 2000 07:54 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for brumans2   Click Here to Email brumans2     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 28279372
yea, you where close, flax seed oil is 130 calories, you had it as 125 for olive oil.. so only 5 calories off .. anyway if your thinking about purchasing flax seed oil at your grocery store, well think again, they dont sell them at grocery stores like meijers, or krogers, of any place. You'd have to purchase some at your local health food store.

IP: Logged

nobu
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 142)
posted June 30, 2000 10:38 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for nobu   Click Here to Email nobu     Edit/Delete Message
What! there are many grochery stores that sell the same quality stuff as health food stores, you just have to shop around; just make sure its organic anf cold pressed.

IP: Logged

brumans2
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 145)
posted June 30, 2000 11:34 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for brumans2   Click Here to Email brumans2     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 28279372
I was saying the POPULAR grocery stores dont have them

like
Meijers, K-Mart, Krogers, ex. i'm sure if someone bought a grocery store and made there own "company store" in one and only one location then they could have whatever they want in it ..

IP: Logged

WCP
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 1216)
posted June 30, 2000 12:38 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for WCP   Click Here to Email WCP     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 39184064
Being female, and at your weight, your cal. look good, I would bump the carbs to about 100g a day, and bump your protein to at least 200g a day. At anytime your cutting your carbs down you need to slam higher amounts of protein for muscle preservation, and body fuel.

later,
WCP

IP: Logged

Diablo's Xstasy
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 75)
posted July 01, 2000 03:16 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Diablo's Xstasy   Click Here to Email Diablo's Xstasy     Edit/Delete Message
I just don't want to take in too much protien. My family has a history of kidney problems and kidney stones. Id hate to have to pee that thing out, ouch would that hurt!!!
I'm just going to see how my body react to that first, and my carbs are at 100, sorry they're at 97 and with a protien shake that'll bump them up a carb or two. Designer Protein has a 3 carbs 1 fat and 20g of protien shake.

Thanks for the help =o)
At least I know Im doing this right

IP: Logged

WCP
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 1216)
posted July 01, 2000 03:05 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for WCP   Click Here to Email WCP     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 39184064
Ok sounds good...

I wouldnt think that your at that big of a risk of kidney stones at 200g a day..Ive been running 300-400 daily for the past 3 years...and no problems....see how that works..if you dont get what you want..then bump it up..

Later,
WCP

IP: Logged

Diablo's Xstasy
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 75)
posted July 01, 2000 03:28 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Diablo's Xstasy   Click Here to Email Diablo's Xstasy     Edit/Delete Message
Thanks sweetie. I'll probably end up bumping it up anyway because this doesn't seem like it's enough food for me, I ate like this yesterday and today and Im still hungry, but maybe thats cause I have to go out and get the shake. I might drink 2 shakes a day instead of one bringing me closer to 200g of protien.

=o)

IP: Logged

MS
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 469)
posted July 01, 2000 08:28 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for MS   Click Here to Email MS     Edit/Delete Message
I wouldn't worry about the protein too much either. Because you're on a calorie restricted diet you will be burning almost all of the protein for fuel, and excreting very little to none. You only need to worry about high protein diets when you're also on a high or maintenance calorie diet. Otherwsie I think the diet looks good (when you get the extra protein in ya). 150 grams sounds good, 200 is getting a bit high (remember she's only around 100 pounds LBM).

Good luck.

IP: Logged

Diablo's Xstasy
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 75)
posted July 01, 2000 10:54 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Diablo's Xstasy   Click Here to Email Diablo's Xstasy     Edit/Delete Message
Thanks MS!!!
Hearing this from you definately reassures me that I am doing something right. I'm going to get designer protein and have 2 to 3 shakes a day, I might make the eggs in the morning with a shake one meal and then make another meal... I don't know I'll figure it out, because designer protein had only about 17grams of protien per serving. Maybe Ill take 2 servings at once. Ick I had my oatmeal this morning and I still cant get used to the taste of plain oatmeal. Yuck
It'll do though.

Thanks again it means Im on the right track and I should be showing some improvement soon =o)

Dx

IP: Logged

Austin316
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 315)
posted July 02, 2000 02:03 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Austin316   Click Here to Email Austin316     Edit/Delete Message
If you need something to bump up your protein get a meal replacement. I got 60 packs of Metaform (45g protein) for $55. I got 60% off the original price. You just have to look around. You should never go below 1 gram of protein per body pound. Stick to 1 gram per body lb and you will be fine. And remember to cut carbs after 5 or 6

IP: Logged

Diablo's Xstasy
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 75)
posted July 02, 2000 02:52 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Diablo's Xstasy   Click Here to Email Diablo's Xstasy     Edit/Delete Message
Doesn't metaform have carbs and fat in it?
I take my carbs in two meals during the day.
In the morning after my cardio workout and at night right before my lifting workout. The other three meals that I am going to be having are going to be protien meals =o)
Who knows maybe even little me will be in a competition one of these days, LOL.

Dx

IP: Logged

WCP
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 1216)
posted July 02, 2000 08:02 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for WCP   Click Here to Email WCP     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 39184064
Actually I believe that higher protein levels are very, very necessary when calorie restricting, and on a low carb diet.

Yep, your body will burn alot of protein for energy...so then what does your muscle get if it dont have some protein left over for recovery??...it gets consumed as well. Your body will cannibalize itself to keep running efficiently. So I would suggest unless you want to risk some muscle loss while dieting, you keep your protein levels up.

later,
WCP

IP: Logged

MS
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 469)
posted July 02, 2000 08:26 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for MS   Click Here to Email MS     Edit/Delete Message
You go girl! I had a PT client last year with partial kidney failure that wanted to compete. She had her blood and urine work done every 4 weeks while she was dieting and had the best kidney test results of her life on her diet! She had a lean body mass of around 105 (132 total bodyweight) 5'2". She ate 1500 cals per day, 150 grams protein, 100 grams starchy carbs, 50 grams fibrous carbs and 30 grams fat. She got down to around 8%bf after 16 weeks on this diet (one cheat meal per week). There was no sign of any excess nitrogen excretion on this diet which seems to support the notion that all the protein you eat will be burned instead of burdening your kidneys. Good luck.

------------------
The Mad Scientist

IP: Logged

Austin316
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 315)
posted July 03, 2000 02:08 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Austin316   Click Here to Email Austin316     Edit/Delete Message
The Metaform packet has 21 grams of carbs, 45 grams of protein, and I think about 2-4 grams of fat. Meal replacements are great cause they basically contain a multivitamin and if you mix it with 2 cups of skim milk thats 61 grams of protein. DX, If you need to up your protein intake I recommend taking one of these either as yopur first meal or post workout meal (you need carbs after a workout even if it is in the evening.)

IP: Logged

Caesar
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 77)
posted July 05, 2000 10:01 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Caesar     Edit/Delete Message
The calories look pretty low for someone who is 140 ... keep in mind that dropping your calories too fast will slow down your metabolism. Do you know what your Basal Metabolic Rate is?

When you lower your carbs, up the fat to compensate. And don't be scared of carbs. The trend for low carb diets is just that - a trend. And it can be very dangerous if not done properly. Unless you are prepping for a contest, I would stick with moderate carbs.

I also noticed things that sounded like they were packaged (oatmeal and chicken, for instance - my apologies if they aren't pre-packaged) ... I'd stay away from ALL processed foods. Use things like 100% rolled oats, natural peanut butter, etc.

And don't forget the water.

------------------
BRING THE PAIN

IP: Logged

skydancer
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 306)
posted July 05, 2000 12:38 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for skydancer   Click Here to Email skydancer     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 76679089
My thoughts exactly Caesar - try to avoid food that are heavily processed. Whole foods are much better for you nutritionally.

Definately bring your cals up to 1800-1900 area. Thats what has been working for me.

(Love the quote C - bring the pain!)

[This message has been edited by skydancer (edited July 05, 2000).]

IP: Logged

MS
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 469)
posted July 05, 2000 04:06 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for MS   Click Here to Email MS     Edit/Delete Message
I think she has been well informed on the
'evils' of processed foods. As for calories, I see a trend on many of these news groups to look at the weight on the scales when making calorie recommendations. This works OK for someone who is not 10-20 %bf, but at 30%bf Diablo's Xstasy doesn't really have a lot of metabolically active bodyweight. Now I AM a long time proponent of making sure that dieters get enough calories, carbs, etc... but I think 1800 cals per day for someone with a LBM of around 100 lbs is unrealistic for a weight loss diet. Maybe we can agree to disagree?

------------------
The Mad Scientist

IP: Logged

skydancer
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 306)
posted July 05, 2000 05:57 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for skydancer   Click Here to Email skydancer     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 76679089
Good point MS as usual...what works for one may not work for the other...but I can't handle that low of cal - I end up binging every three days!

IP: Logged

MS
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 469)
posted July 05, 2000 06:58 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for MS   Click Here to Email MS     Edit/Delete Message
So skydancer, is the diet still working? I couldn't find out from Mr. Muscles original post what your %bf was on this diet, but I assumed at 5'6" and 144 lbs that you weren't carrying as much fat as Diablos Xstasy. My point about the calories was that, even though you and Diablos X weigh about the same, Diablos X almost certainly has a lot less LEAN mass than you do. She does not need to feed her fat because it's almost inert, metabolically speaking. As such she should also be able to stick to a lower calorie diet without needing to binge everyday. But I may be wrong about your %bf. In other words, at 140 lbs, 30% bf diablos X would have a metabolic mass of around 93 lbs. If, on the other hand I assume skydancer has a %bf of around 20% (I pulled that out of a hat) at 144lbs, this equates to a metabolically active lean mass of around 115 lbs. The difference in calories based on, say 16 cals per pound of LEAN MASS would be 1488 for Diablos X, and 1840 for skydancer. That's why I say that in some cases it's important to ignore the absolute weight on the scales and look at the composition of the person.

There may be confusion because I said in another post If a women couldn't lose weight on 12 cals per pound bodyweight then I would rather see her increase her cardio rather than decrease her calories. What I didn't mention that this was just a rough figure and assumes the women is under 20%bf to begin with. Much above 20% bf and this rule no longer works so well.

This is all academic though. What's important is Diablos Xs results. Have you managed to increase your protein yet?

------------------
The Mad Scientist

IP: Logged

Caesar
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 77)
posted July 06, 2000 09:22 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Caesar     Edit/Delete Message
Although I agree that a higher LBM will burn more calories than a lower LBM, 1200 is still pretty low for someone who weighs 140lbs - regardless of LBM.

I think I suggested finding the Basal Metabolic Rate which will FIRMLY determine how many calories are required, rather than multiplying body weight by a number pulled out of a hat.

If your body is accoustumed to consuming 2500 calories (rough estimate), and then you drop that number by half, you can be sure that your metabolism will slow down.

------------------
BRING THE PAIN

IP: Logged

skydancer
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 306)
posted July 06, 2000 12:25 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for skydancer   Click Here to Email skydancer     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 76679089
MS - I don't know what my bf% is (calipers are on there way to me) A few years ago it was 22% but then I gained weight/lost weight - you know the cycle. Since march I've gotten "serious" with weight training. The diet still feels good to me, I'm at 141 now but my measurments on hips and thighs are changing dramatically. Not to mention progress in building my upper body. So I know the lean mass is packing on. My protein intake is 200+ - feels great!!

I did change up my routine 3wks ago - hitting heavier weights now - and I find I am hungrier than usual. But I am still trying to lose a bit of fat...I'm wondering if I shouldn't up my intake a bit??

IP: Logged

MS
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 469)
posted July 06, 2000 03:32 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for MS   Click Here to Email MS     Edit/Delete Message
I think this thread has been running independently on two different discussion boards, which makes it difficult for everyone to keep up.

Here is DX's original post from the women's board, which is how some of us know that she HASN'T been eating 2500 cals per day, and that she HAS already made some good progress.

"I posted a similar message on the Diet board, but I'm a woman and I thought you women might be able to help
a bit better and hey I can use all of the advice i can get.
Basically Ive been working out for two years and recently got very very serious about it.
3 months ago I weighed 136.5 32% bodyfat, Im 5'1.
Now I weigh 141.8lbs. and am at 30% bodyfat.

I have been on such a strict diet it's not funny. I do have one cheat day where I can eat anything I want until
5pm and after that it's only chicken, fish, or salad.
I eat everyday 1400 cal, 8g fat, 250 carbs, 112 sugars, and 140 protien.
I work out 5-6 days a week training 1-2 bodyparts in 45minutes to an hour, sometime a little more if it's two. I
do a routine similar to my boyfriends.
And I do 30min high intensity cardio 15min low intensity 4-5 times a week.
When I lift I usually do 15 reps 3 sets last set of each exercise is supersetted.
I used to lift very heavy and do only up to 8 reps 3 sets with last one supersetted.
now I can still lift as heavy as I was if not heavier then I was when I was doing 8 reps.
Also I began taking Xenadrine Im up to 5 caps a day was taking 4...

Please help me Im at a wits end and I've asked professional bodybuilders and they cant really figure it out. My
body should be developing much more rapidly and burning fat quicker as well.
I dont care about my weight as long as it looks good and feminine, I just want my bodyfat down to at least
20% that'll be a huge change for me loosing 10%."


To which there were many replies concerning her high sugar intake, as well as some specific recommendations:

IF I take what you say at face value (and this is a virtual board so I have to), there's some things you need to
address right away. Somebody's mathematics is of whack. 250gm carbs + 140gm protein + 8gm fat (and I'm
suspicious of this fat value because of the types and quantities of food your eating) adds up to ~1650 cals
per day. At around 100 lbs LEAN body weight (which is what I calculate you at) you should be eating No
more than 1400-1600cals.

And if you were one of my PT clients and you were SERIOUS about losing the fat I would ask tou to cut out
ALL processed carbs. 60-80 grams per day from unadulterated whole grains, plus some extra carbs from fresh
vegetables. I would also have you add NO SEASONINGS (including salt, soy sauce, dressings etc...) except
for spices such as pepper, ginger, coriander, cumin, garlic,....
Your last 'starchy carbs' would be no later than 2pm, and your last (protein and veggie) meal would be AT
LEAST 2 hours before bedtime. That's just for starters. Your day would look something like this:

Meal 1 45 grams carbs
40 grams protein
1/2 tsp flax oil

Meal 2 25 grams carbs
40 grams protein
1/2 tsp flax oil

Meal 3 15 grams carbs
40 grams protein
1/2 tsp flax oil
1 Cup broccoli

Meal 4 2-3 cups fresh fibrous veggies
40 grams protein
1/2 tsp flax oil

Meal 5 2-3 cups fresh fibrous veggies
40 grams protein
1/2 tsp flax oil

This is 200 gams protein, 150 grams total carbs, and around 20-25 grams fat for a total of around 1600 cals per day.

Your starchy carbs would come from oats, whole wheat such as shredded wheat, brown rice, maybe some
boiled spuds. You should try some other prtein mixes. Surely they can't all make you throw up? Have you
tried soy protein for instance?

You would also take a range of multi-vits and minerals (read WarLobo's post on this topic).

As I say, this is just for starters.....and of course it's just my opinion. Obviously this diet would need to be fine-tuned as you go to optimize results, including increasing calories, throwing in cheat meals, etc...

The Mad Scientist

There was also lots of other advice given on the women's discussion board which have gone into DX's final diet choice. Hopefully this brings everyone up to speed on why she's where she's at on this board.

What do you guys and gals think she should change/modify. Please be specific as to what you would have her eat and when. I think so far we all agree she needs to get her protein intake up from 100 grams!


------------------
The Mad Scientist

[This message has been edited by MS (edited July 06, 2000).]

IP: Logged

Caesar
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 77)
posted July 06, 2000 05:32 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Caesar     Edit/Delete Message
Okay, this is a little better

I agree that calorie intake should be around 1400-1600. Actually today I was thinking about it and was pretty set on 1500. As for the macronutrient composition, I'd keep the protein at about 1-1.5g/lb of lean body mass. That would put it around 150g tops. Up the efa's to compensate for loss of calories.

Other than that, I think the diet layout and timing you suggested looks great. Very similar to what I have someone on right now.

------------------
BRING THE PAIN

IP: Logged

Diablo's Xstasy
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 75)
posted July 08, 2000 12:58 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Diablo's Xstasy   Click Here to Email Diablo's Xstasy     Edit/Delete Message
Sorry that I have not been around, My boyfriend took this week as a vacation and we've been out doing tons of things like great adventure and the such, I have to admit it's getting slightly annoying carrying around all that food with me, but Ive been managing.
I have to admit I have not followed my diet 100% completely, but only because the gym I go to has not gotten in their shipment yet of the protien powder that I want and my boyfriend can get it for me 1/2 off therefore Id rather wait.
What I have been doing to compansate it adding another whole can of tuna with no mayo or anything and also Ive added 2 pieces of chicken at night and 2 more eggs in the morning. I figured that this would be good until the powder comes in, I think my additions haven't brought me too far off of my diet and if Im still hungry I usually have a little bit of salad, but that hasn't been happening lately.
I do admit to the fact that yesterday at great adventure I had a piece of fudge, can't help it when everyone else is eating mcdonlds in front of you. How rude was that?! But hey when they're fat and slobby at least when our friends girlfriend is, I'll be nice and thin and muscular.
I know this is totally off of the topic, but just wanted to let you all know that Im doing good with the diet. Ive missed two days at the gym this week, but with all the walking Ive been doing lately and the fact that its not a good time of the month for me right now I figured it was okay to miss a day or two.
I do already notice a few cuts coming out on my arms and such, but I dont know if thats because Im getting darker or if it's cause Im lugging around this damn cooler everywhere we go so I can eat my healthy meals while they eat their crap... Sorry sorry I know Im back on that, just annoying when Im eating my tuna someones eating a waffle swirled cone with extra sprinkles infront of me and my boyfriends the worst ordering a supersized mcdonalds meal with fries!!!! Sorry again, but hey doesn't this show dedication? At least I hope it does.
I'll post my new weight and bf% in a couple of days, right now all bloated from drinking so much water, my body's not quite used to it yet.
Night
Dx

IP: Logged

All times are ET (US)

Post New Topic  
Hop to:

Contact Us | Back to Elite Fitness

Elite Fitness Discussion Board

Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board (UltimateBB), Version 5.42a
� Infopop Corporation (formerly Madrona Park, Inc.), 1998-1999.