Navbar

  Elite Fitness Bodybuilding, Anabolics, Diet, Life Extension, Wellness, Supplements, and Training Boards
  Women's Discussion Board
  A question about body fat for my girlfriend.

Post New Topic  
profile | register | preferences | faq | search

Author Topic:   A question about body fat for my girlfriend.
Rugby

Pro Bodybuilder

Posts: 545
From:Dallas, Texas, USA
Registered: Sep 2000

posted January 09, 2001 02:32 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


They tested my girlfriend's bodyfat at school today and tole her she was 14%... I myself am at 6%bf and she is leaner than me... The guy that tested her is a professional and said that 12% bodyfat is necessary for a girl... She's a size 3 and runs all the time and works out... I dont see how she can be 14%... Any info is appreciated...Thanks


Click Here to See the Profile for Rugby   Click Here to Email Rugby     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
luv2workout

Amateur Bodybuilder

Posts: 220
From:Louisiana
Registered: May 2000

posted January 09, 2001 03:23 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


A woman's bodyfat is always higher than a mans...14% is very good...Look at FC pics, I think she was around 10% bf and she looks absolutely perfect!


Click Here to See the Profile for luv2workout   Click Here to Email luv2workout     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Trinity13

Amateur Bodybuilder

Posts: 64
From:Miami, FL, USA
Registered: Jul 2000

posted January 09, 2001 04:39 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


The 12% b/f is necessary for what? Is she competing in anything that would require her to have a lower body fat? 14% is good for an active female. Females just have more fat than men do, although they make look leaner, specially in the lower body, thighs, hips, butt you get the picture.

------------------
You can not accomplish what your mind can not conceive.


Click Here to See the Profile for Trinity13   Click Here to Email Trinity13     Edit/Delete Message    UIN: 83796777   Reply w/Quote
bikinimom

Moderator

Posts: 2376
From:LaLa Land
Registered: Nov 2000

posted January 09, 2001 04:58 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Are you saying that you think her bodyfat should be lower?

I don't understand why you seem upset.

Please explain it to me.

------------------


....beauty knows no pain.


Click Here to See the Profile for bikinimom   Click Here to Email bikinimom     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
skydancer

Elite Bodybuilder

Posts: 1208
From:Central CA, USA
Registered: May 2000

posted January 09, 2001 05:15 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


The important thing isn't a specific number. BF%'s can be misleading like the numbers on a scale. If she's active, healthy, takes care of herself I would tell her not to worry. 14% sounds terrific to me.

------------------
Patience is a bitter plant, but it has sweet fruit.
Well done is better than well said.


Click Here to See the Profile for skydancer   Click Here to Email skydancer     Edit/Delete Message    UIN: 76679089   Reply w/Quote
MS

Elite Bodybuilder

Posts: 1107
From:Somewhere in the South Pacific
Registered: May 2000

posted January 09, 2001 05:26 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Ignore the %BF measurements. Does she look hot to you? Is she healthy, active and fun to be around?? Does she eat a healthy diet?? %BF measurements don't mean very much unless you have a specific goal in mind, so don't worry about it. Better to be 20% BF and be a warm, compassionate human than to be 6% BF and have an obsessive eating disorder such as Anorexia Nervosa!!!!


Click Here to See the Profile for MS   Click Here to Email MS     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
MP5

Freak

Posts: 1519
From:your nightmares
Registered: Feb 2000

posted January 09, 2001 07:04 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


I might buy the 6% for you, but I have never seen a girl that was 6%. Maybe Kim Chivesky.


Click Here to See the Profile for MP5   Click Here to Email MP5     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Rugby

Pro Bodybuilder

Posts: 545
From:Dallas, Texas, USA
Registered: Sep 2000

posted January 09, 2001 09:21 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


No i wasn't upset at all... I love my girlfriend, and i think she is damn hot...She just knew that i was 6% and found out she was 14% and she freaked out... So i was trying to find out some info for her... It was a big help thanks... That will make her feel much better


Click Here to See the Profile for Rugby   Click Here to Email Rugby     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
FitFossil

Novice

Posts: 7
From:USA
Registered: Jan 2001

posted January 10, 2001 10:53 AM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Comparing body fat percentages between males and females is like comparing apples to oranges. If you could find a male and a female with exactly the same body fat measurement percentage, visually the female would appear much leaner. Both medically and aesthetically, a female can carry a higher body fat percentage.

The % number is meaningless in itself. It can vary by the measurement method, the measurer, or other factors such as the subject's hydration level, whether they just worked out, etc.

The only thing to concentrate on is whether that number is moving in the general direction you want it.


Click Here to See the Profile for FitFossil     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
F1hybrid

Amateur Bodybuilder

Posts: 238
From:
Registered: Aug 2000

posted January 10, 2001 02:01 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Women carry more bodyfat in their lower body than guys, its a function of estrogen. Many appear to have ripped upper bodies, but they are still above 8-10% bodyfat. The only women that I have ever body comp'd below 8% were juiced, with or without GH and CLEN. I've comp'd several of the pro women from 3.7 to 5.5% body fat using several techniques including underwater weighing and DEXA, and backed them up with skinfolds. If a woman is heavily juiced and has been for some time, you have to use a skinfold formula designed for guys or the numbers will be too low.

14% is lean for a female. Generally, natural women will not get below 8-10% unless they are a full blow anoretic and have one + foot in the grave at that point.

Size and the fact she runs means little. I've seen fat size one's and ripped size 10's. In addition, distance runners rarely seem to get as lean as sprinters. Compare olympic sprinters to the distance girls. The sprinters usually have cross-striations in their quads, the distance girls generally don't.

F1


Click Here to See the Profile for F1hybrid   Click Here to Email F1hybrid     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Iron God

Elite Bodybuilder

Posts: 905
From: Parts Unknown
Registered: May 2000

posted January 10, 2001 02:36 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Rugby if your at 6% and your girl is leaner than you.

Guess what...Your not 6%.

Unless your 150Lbs with no muscle you should look leaner than your girl.

How did you get it tested?


IG


Click Here to See the Profile for Iron God   Click Here to Email Iron God     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
skydancer

Elite Bodybuilder

Posts: 1208
From:Central CA, USA
Registered: May 2000

posted January 10, 2001 03:59 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


F1- actually anorexics are often in an "obese" bf classification...their body has eaten most of the muscle and all it has stored is fat (though there is little of that too). This is generally where the body will start actually eating the heart for food.

14%bf is very lean in my opinion. It also depends on how its distributed. My upper body is a lot leaner than my lower. So while my legs have fat on them, my upper body will be nicely cut at 15-16%bf.


Click Here to See the Profile for skydancer   Click Here to Email skydancer     Edit/Delete Message    UIN: 76679089   Reply w/Quote
bikinimom

Moderator

Posts: 2376
From:LaLa Land
Registered: Nov 2000

posted January 10, 2001 04:40 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Sorry I jumped all over you Rugby. Now that I have retracted my claws and come off the ceiling.....What bf% did your girl have in mind? I am at 19% (down from 20% as I have started cutting) and I just had my hubby take pics w/a digital cam last night for a project. From the back, I was blown away. I had no idea that my back had grown so - I was impressed. Was my behind round and soft? Hell yea, I am a GIRL and at 19%bf, of course my derrier will appear round and soft. My legs show very little definition but DAMN do they have shape! As for my upper body it is smooth, but when I training the veins jump out and I am defined to a degree. In the proper light you can just barely see a hint of my abs. Am I bothered by this less-than-contest-ready appearance? HELL NO!

A) I don't intend on competing any earlier than April (and even then it will not be bbing but figure).

B) I won't accept any projects at this given time that require a bf% of below 15%.

Would I be self-conscious if I had to wear a bikini? PERISH THE THOUGHT. As a matter of fact I am getting ready to shoot some glamour/fantasy/artsy stuff in a few weeks and by then I should be closer to 17% which is where I want to be.

What is the reason that your girl is so upset w/a result of 14%bf?

------------------


....beauty knows no pain.


Click Here to See the Profile for bikinimom   Click Here to Email bikinimom     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
F1hybrid

Amateur Bodybuilder

Posts: 238
From:
Registered: Aug 2000

posted January 10, 2001 08:49 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


I used to work with an anorectic trainer. I comp'd her, skinfold, UW weigh and DEXA. She was 4-5% (all measures) stayed that way year round. Had some muscle and was ripped from head to toe. Face was narly looking. Looked like skin stretched across a skull. Hair was thin and dry. Had terrible gas too and lots of it, made the stuff my rotties pass smell like perfume. Too bad, she could have been a pretty girl if she stayed around 10% bodyfat and ate normally. That's why I tell my student's not to go there to lose weight because once you start down that path, there's likely no turning back. Interesting, the media demonizes steroids and promotes anorexia but a woman on test will live a normal life and a hard core anorectic will probably be dead within 2 years. Strange society we live in.

F1


Click Here to See the Profile for F1hybrid   Click Here to Email F1hybrid     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Valkerie

Amateur Bodybuilder

Posts: 70
From:,USA
Registered: Dec 2000

posted January 10, 2001 10:00 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Size 3? Too much smaller and shell look like me. Size 3 is great,and I'm sure shes not showing it. Tell her no worries....


Click Here to See the Profile for Valkerie   Click Here to Email Valkerie     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
skydancer

Elite Bodybuilder

Posts: 1208
From:Central CA, USA
Registered: May 2000

posted January 11, 2001 01:10 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Amen to that F1...very strange society. I know a lot of anoretics are that low bf - but some are considered obese too. Now thats a weird concept if I ever heard one. You are dying from starvation but you fall into an obese catagory. Like well muscled men/women whose measurments/weight put us in obese catagories from all those silly weight charts...when they are really at the highest level of fitness.

------------------
Patience is a bitter plant, but it has sweet fruit.
Well done is better than well said.


Click Here to See the Profile for skydancer   Click Here to Email skydancer     Edit/Delete Message    UIN: 76679089   Reply w/Quote

All times are ET (US)

Post New Topic  
Hop to:

Contact Us | Back to Elite Fitness | Privacy Statement

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.45c



HomeArticlesDiscussion BoardsFeatured SitesContact Us� ReportsSupplementsShopping