The guy, who I think is Shawn Phillips, in the old EAS ad that said "Your personality may be important but it won't make you look good in a tank top". Shawn Phillips doesn't look to bad either.
Another one is 1968 Mr. America Jim Haislop, but with slightly better leg development. I love the way his upper body looks on page 141 in The Poliquin Principles.
Also, which I also in The Poliquin Principles on page 94 is Mike Dayton, a strongman from the late 70's early 80's. Once again though I'd like better legs. I guess he held a world record for one-arm chins and often opened his shows performing 100 chins off a ceiling girder.
Craig Titus, though often times looks to big for me, has a very pleasing look as well. I don't think I'd want to be that big but I really do like the way he looks.