I'd concentrate on expanding revenue a lot further before looking into any sort of equity offering - there's no appetite on the Street for dot-coms right now.
I'd suggest your best bet is to further expand the web site - you already have a huge on-line community to draw from, so offer more for sale that they want/need. A few ideas:
* Take the ideas that are on this thread for books, but make them on-line books, either by download or by password-accessed web pages.
* An on-line magazine by subscription only - offer a few articles free and the rest by subscription. This is the model that Salon (just about the last of the web-only magazines that's survived) has gone with, and it seems to be working well for them.
* Expand your own brand of supplements further, and offer a limited number of products (quality-vetted by you) from other companies (avoid the R&D expense where you can - no need to reinvent the wheel on some things like anti-oxidants.)
* Along the same lines - limited advertising from reputable firms (pre-vetted by you.) Might be eaier to concentrate more along the non-supplement side (e.g. training clothes, dress clothes, etc.) to avoid the "we give the 'seal of approval' to whoever can pay for ads" syndrome that always seems to come with this sort of program (I'm not gonna name names here.)
* Offer reviews of mainstream BB/powerlifting books, videos, etc, with a click-through to Amazon to buy (and generate commisisons for Elite) if they carry it. Everyone does this.
Beyond the web, if you have the capital, have you considered opening a gym in NYC? (It's my understanding you're based in Manhattan?) Besides being a base for Elite-sponsored seminars, training, etc., it could be a money-maker in its own right - although there's a damn NYSC every 50 feet, there's a real shortage of hard-core gyms. Position it for maximum subway convenience and offer a good locker room to get the before work/lunch/after work trainers, and you could have a winner.
Also, besides traditiional personal training, you could offer a "consultancy" of sorts - from reading Elite, I see a lot of people who want more info on training, etc. to meet various goals, including going into competition. But if you go to a NYSC-style health club, or even a hard-core gym at odd hours, who do you talk to if you don't want to hire a trainer but just want one-on-one help with questions like contest prep, etc? Personally, I have no interest in hiring a trainer, but would hire a "consultant" occasionally. This could be a big winner, especially since those outside the NY area could combine it with a weekend in NY. You can strike a deal with a hotel or two to offer decent rates, perhaps even get a few airfare deals going with the smaller lines (JetBlue, perhaps?)