Circumcision - a serious discussion

[spongebob]

You are right. I phrased the question wrong. It should be:

Does the memory of an experience that involves the stimuli that can be interpreted as pain become traumatic after the infant has established what pain is?

well you havnt established the fact that an infant, that we assumed can not feel pain, can have memory.

 

[scriptfactory]

There has to be some kind of (noninvasive) machine that can tap into a childs nervous system and settle this once and for all. And if there isn't a machine like that they need to invent one. Dang.

 

[Mr. dB]

But I wonder if they have any recollection of that pain after they've grown up.

Whether or not anyone has any recollecton of neonatal circumcision, they certainly have one reminder -- a nasty scar in place of a functioning foreskin.

 

[Ulcasterdropout]

Whether or not anyone has any recollecton of neonatal circumcision, they certainly have one reminder -- a nasty scar in place of a functioning foreskin.

True. And it can be worse. Of all the porn I've seen. I've never seen a circ scar as bad as mine. It's a large black ring

 

[spongebob]

There has to be some kind of (noninvasive) machine that can tap into a childs nervous system and settle this once and for all. And if there isn't a machine like that they need to invent one. Dang.

check with spacedragon, he has a crazy machine.

 

[BrothaBill]

check with spacedragon, he has a crazy machine.

That reminds me of Sherman and Dr Peabody, "Sherman, set the Wayback Machine to 1492.."
SpaceDragon is crrrrrrrraaaaaaaaazzzzzzzzzzzyyyyyy!!!! The Dude has like thirty flipping page thread, and they are LONG posts!! I could only read like the first two pages, actually just the first page and then I read that one time the last page and told him how fucked up he is, dude that's definitely not me!!

 

[spongebob]

That reminds me of Sherman and Dr Peabody, "Sherman, set the Wayback Machine to 1492.."
SpaceDragon is crrrrrrrraaaaaaaaazzzzzzzzzzzyyyyyy!!!! The Dude has like thirty flipping page thread, and they are LONG posts!! I could only read like the first two pages, actually just the first page and then I read that one time the last page and told him how fucked up he is, dude that's definitely not me!!

well he does alot of copy/paste. alot. not only from his previous post but he steals stuff off the net.