A lot wouldn't agree, but a lot would that were lied to being told to eat as much as they like and lose weight, but they dont. Yeah, the basics of the diet work, no doubt about it. But he misrepresents the studies, lies about a fat mobilizing mystery substance, says fat loss stops when too many carbs are eaten, I can go on.
NOT everyone gets a hunger blunting effect from low carbs, high fat and protein, CCK release is the primary reason for the blunting, as well as slower gastric emptying from the higher fat. Some people will overeat when given a licence to "eat all you want", and gain weight. He dismisses the calorie aspect of weight loss, and says if fat loss stops lower carbs more, while this works in the sense of altering total body fuel utilization more towards fat, calories are of prime importance regardless of diet composition. Yeah, weight can be lost, lots of it, but it doesn't take away from the facts that he misprepresents, giving low carb diets a bad name in many ways. And its Lipolysis-Ketosis, not the other way around as he says it.