List of Academic All-America® honors per school, broken down by Division; List of Most AAA selections since 2000 (.pdf)
The top 10 schools in total Academic All-America® honorees (as of July 2013)
(click above link for full school listings):
University of Nebraska 307
Notre Dame 231
MIT 204
Penn State 182
Stanford 176
Augustana (Ill.) 146
Emory University 144
Nebraska Wesleyan 141
University of Florida 127
Bucknell University 125