Squat/deadlift or squat/bench press?

Posted: 10-May-2001 03:23 AM

Welcome to the EliteFitness.com Bodybuilding Site! Please join this discussion about Squat/deadlift or squat/bench press? within the Power Lifting category.

Excerpt: I'm a natural and I do 3 workouts per week.I am inproving bench press so I want to train it 2 time per week.The problem is that in at least 1 workout I have to bench with squat or deadlift ,so: 1) if I choose deadlift it's too much for shoulders ; 2) If I choose squat,the day after I am too tired. ADVICE ??...

Read more or register here to join the discussion below...

Squat/deadlift or squat/bench press?
Go Back  EliteFitness.com Bodybuilding Forums > Fitness, Bodybuilding & Sports > Power Lifting
User Name
Password
Click to Register Now!
Register Blogs Platinum Chat Gallery Karma Store Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 10-May-2001, 03:23 AM   #1
Frank Zane
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Posts: 6
Karmic Power: 0
Karma Hits: 10
Frank Zane has only a little positive karma
I'm a natural and I do 3 workouts per week.I am inproving bench press so I want to train it 2 time per week.The problem is that in at least 1 workout I have to bench with squat or deadlift ,so:
1) if I choose deadlift it's too much for shoulders ;
2) If I choose squat,the day after I am too tired.

ADVICE ??
Offline
Gallery of Frank Zane  
Reply With Quote
Old 10-May-2001, 11:54 AM   #2
Hannibal
 
Hannibal's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Gender: M
Posts: 5,820
Karmic Power: 111
Karma Hits: 8523
Hannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karma
The same muscles that increase the deadlift also increase the squat. It is not neccesary to preform the deadlift that often. The perfect solution would be to train four days a week. Two days for bench; one to work on speed and techinque...the other to work on maximum effort. Then the other two days can be devoted to the squat/dl...one for speed the other for strength. The best way to increase your deadlift is to stop deadlifting.

Check out...www.elitefitnesssystems.com
Offline
Gallery of Hannibal  
Proud Supporter of EliteFitness.com!
Click here to upgrade for Unrestricted Search, Live Chat, Full Size Pics, Private Boards, 5000 PM's, and more...
Reply With Quote
Old 17-May-2001, 07:31 AM   #3
bigger faster stronger
 
Join Date: Feb 2001
Posts: 21
Karmic Power: 0
Karma Hits: 10
bigger faster stronger has only a little positive karma
Quote:
The best way to increase your deadlift is to stop deadlifting.

hannibal... what do you mean... are you saying that you should stop deadlifting all together except at competition and things... do you think your deadlift can be increased more by just workin on your muscle groups that aid in the deadlift?... thanks
Offline
Gallery of bigger faster stronger  
Reply With Quote
Old 17-May-2001, 07:40 AM   #4
Hannibal
 
Hannibal's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Gender: M
Posts: 5,820
Karmic Power: 111
Karma Hits: 8523
Hannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karmaHannibal has asked that you avoid touching the bloated green karma
That's exactly what I am saying. The same muscles that squat also deadlift. So working them both is a quick way to stall your progress. Check out the above link...go to the articles and read about deadlift training.

Good Luck
Offline
Gallery of Hannibal  
Proud Supporter of EliteFitness.com!
Click here to upgrade for Unrestricted Search, Live Chat, Full Size Pics, Private Boards, 5000 PM's, and more...
Reply With Quote
Old 17-May-2001, 07:52 AM   #5
bigger faster stronger
 
Join Date: Feb 2001
Posts: 21
Karmic Power: 0
Karma Hits: 10
bigger faster stronger has only a little positive karma
alright... will do... thanks for your help... i am kind of new to the powerlifting scene
Offline
Gallery of bigger faster stronger  
Reply With Quote
Old 17-May-2001, 01:07 PM   #6
b fold the truth
 
b fold the truth's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2000
Gender: M
Posts: 15,465
Karmic Power: 135
Karma Hits: 46832
b fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karmab fold the truth sold someones soul for karma
Hmmmm...I am going to slightly disagree with Hannibal, even though I hate to. I would keep deadlifting, and maybe train the bench press to a lighter fashion on dead day. I used to have a hard day...and a pump up day for basically every body part.

Not to argue...would just be hard for me to stop deadlifting...if I read the post correctly.

B True
Cyprus
Offline
Gallery of b fold the truth  
Proud Supporter of EliteFitness.com!
Click here to upgrade for Unrestricted Search, Live Chat, Full Size Pics, Private Boards, 5000 PM's, and more...
Reply With Quote
Old 17-May-2001, 02:34 PM   #7
powerlifterjay
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Gender: M
Posts: 1,194
Karmic Power: 0
Karma Hits: 19
powerlifterjay has only a little positive karma
I would agree with Hannibal. The squat and dead use alot of the same muscles but i would throw in goodmorning, moderate reps 3 to 8. And yes bench twice a week either flat heavy day 1, Day 2 bench do speed Or just go light for reps and push it as fast as you can. Speed work ofor th ebench is 50 to 60% of your max weight done 8 sets of 3 reps and push th eweight as fast as you can. Rest no more then 1 minute between sets. Then move on to Tri accessory work. And 4 days is the ideal amount for powerlifting. we need more rest then most , now i said only most bodybuilders. But if you had to pick which exercise to can on an either or basis...drop the deadlifting.
Offline
Gallery of powerlifterjay  
Reply With Quote
Old 18-May-2001, 12:30 PM   #8
Frank Zane
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Posts: 6
Karmic Power: 0
Karma Hits: 10
Frank Zane has only a little positive karma
One moment ! Deadlift is not only a muscolar matter,it needs a good technical,so, I not agree with deadlifting little. I think that the right thing to do is to alternate heavy and speed workouts and the bench press alone or,at most,with good morning .
Offline
Gallery of Frank Zane  
Reply With Quote
Old 19-May-2001, 02:42 PM   #9
MadCow1
 
Posts: n/a
Karmic Power: 0
Karma Hits:
Progressing in the deadlift without any pulling exercises is difficult at best and should only be considered by someone very advanced or plateaued in another lift and willing to drop DL focus. Bill Star had an interesting program for this but it still consisted of endless pulling so not really applicable.

Bench in alternating heavy and light/speed days. On the light/speed day do either of the 2 other exercises first. I would recommend squats but it depends on one's body.
  Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools  Search this Thread 
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes  Rate This Thread 
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:40 PM.